Paterson School Safety Audit Finds Missing Police Notification Records
An internal review of 300 safety reports in the New Jersey school district revealed widespread documentation gaps and inconsistent reporting procedures.
- By Jesse Jacobs
- November 16, 2026
An internal audit of roughly 300 safety reports in the Paterson Public School District found that none documented whether police were notified, raising concerns over the accuracy of state-mandated safety data.
During a Nov. 10 Board of Education workshop meeting, Security Director Dalton Price told commissioners that his department audited about 300 reports from the previous school year out of more than 1,000 filed. Price explained that his office transfers data from school-submitted forms directly into the state portal. Because the reports are incomplete when they reach security, inaccurate figures get submitted to the state.
Under district protocol, principals must vet incident reports at the school level before routing them through the assistant superintendent's office to the security department. Price noted that staff members have not consistently followed this chain of review.
Workflow breakdowns and form limitations have further skewed the records. Price noted that separate staff members sometimes complete the state safety form and the district's internal School Incident Report for the same event without comparing notes, resulting in conflicting accounts. In another instance, a principal marked that police were involved in a fight simply because officers were stationed on another floor of the building, even though the officers did not respond to the altercation.
Price also cited a design flaw in the state form, which features a checkbox to indicate police involvement but offers no separate option to confirm officers were not involved. Leaving the field blank forces security staff to assume no police notification occurred. Additionally, the security department does not train principals on how to complete the forms.
Correcting historical records would require officials to manually cross-reference more than 1,000 state safety reports against internal incident logs. For the 2026-27 school year, 19 incidents involving police have been reported since September, though staff are still entering a backlog of paperwork because the state portal did not open until Nov. 2. Board commissioners asked the superintendent to explore new data-integrity procedures to resolve the discrepancies.
According to a TAPinto Paterson report, the missing documentation does not necessarily mean police were never contacted during those 300 incidents, only that the reports failed to confirm whether notification took place. The outlet also noted that the district has not yet clarified whether previously submitted state figures will be amended or if mandatory staff training will be introduced, as school officials had not responded to requests for comment.