Civil Rights, Disabilities, Mental Illnesses Advocacy Groups Oppose Florida Database

Civil Rights, Disabilities, Mental Illnesses Advocacy Groups Oppose Florida Database

Thirty-two advocacy organizations are fighting a plan that calls for a Florida state database to prevent school shootings. They have written a letter explaining why they disagree with the bill.

A new Florida state database is intended to prevent school shootings, but 32 advocacy organizations disagree and have written a letter to Republican Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis explaining why the program could be more harmful than helpful.

The organizations include civil rights groups, including the American Civil Liberties Union, Southern Poverty Law center, and several that advocate for people with disabilities or mental illnesses.

“We ask that you immediately halt the state’s construction of this database and, instead, create a commission of parents, students, and experts … to determine whether a state database would actually help to identify school safety threats and would not pose undue harm to students,” the letter states.

The letter continues on to explain that this attempt at mass surveillance of students could discourage students from reporting bullying, other instances of violence, or mental health needs based on the fear they could be labeled as a potential threat to the school.

According to the Tampa Bay Times, there were two school safety laws passed by the state Legislator following 2018’s shooting in Parkland that require this “data repository.” It would be built to include information from law enforcement agencies, schools, students’ social media posts, the Department of Juvenile Justice and the Department of Children and Families. All this information would be collected and shared between agencies under the assumption that it would help identify red flags. In addition, the database could be collecting whether children have been victims of bullying based on race, religion, disability, and sexual orientation; have been treated for substance abuse or undergone involuntary psychiatric assessments; and if they have been in foster care. It is scheduled to be completed by August 1.

According to Education Week, the database was supposed to be operational six months ago, but bureaucratic delays and concerns over exactly how much sensitive information can legally be shared put its introduction on hold.

Stephanie Langer, a lawyer with the Miami-based Disability Independence Group Inc., said she believes that the database could create more problems for students through stigmatization.

“Kids who have a meltdown at school are already being arrested, suspended, Baker Acted, pushed out of school,” Langer said. “When they want to get rid of a kid, they call them a safety risk. This database is going to give them permission to do more of that.”

The letter says that the organizations are concerned this database could pose a risk by labeling students as threats when they are not.

“We are deeply concerned that the program will be used to label students as threats based on data that has no documented link to violent behavior,” the letter says. “We believe this database represents a significant safety risk.”

About the Author

Kaitlyn DeHaven is the Associate Content Editor for the Infrastructure Solutions Group at 1105 Media.

Featured

  • How Campus Security Became an Art of Disappearing

    Walk across any university campus at 8:47 a.m. on a Tuesday, and you'll witness something remarkable. Thousands of students stream through buildings, carrying everything from vintage MacBooks to oversized coffee cups, lost in conversations about weekend plans or upcoming exams. If the right weapons detection is in place, most will never notice the sophisticated security measures protecting them. This invisibility can represent the highest achievement in modern campus security design. Read Now

  • Torrance USD Standardizes Its Mass Communications

    The Torrance Unified School District is a cornerstone of the Torrance, Calif. community, dedicated to providing a high-quality education that prepares students for success in college, career, and life. Serving a diverse student population, Torrance USD delivers a comprehensive and enriching educational experience from kindergarten through high school. The school district comprises 17 elementary, eight middle, and five high schools, one continuation high school, and one alternative high school.  Read Now

  • How a Rural School District Enhanced Safety, Reduced Vaping, and Improved Efficiency by Modernizing Security

    As educational leaders, our primary mission is creating safe, productive learning environments where our students can thrive. Today, that unfortunately means addressing ever-evolving challenges that range from security threats to the growing epidemic of student vaping, all while managing tight budgets and (for many of us) geographically dispersed facilities. Read Now

  • Turning Surveillance Into Strategy: AI’s Role in Driving Proactive Security

    Video surveillance has long been part of the campus safety toolkit, indispensable for investigating security incidents after they occur and a valuable tool for proactive deterrent. Read Now