How Realistic Should Active Shooter Drills Be?

A major part of school security is preparedness for the unthinkable. Active shooter drills are one way to prepare students, teachers, and administrators for an event.

But law enforcement and school districts continue to struggle with the question of how realistic should these drills be. In early April, at Snowflake High School in Snowflake, Arizona, the school conducted an unannounced drill.

According to local news station 12News, instead of bell for a drill, a “more serious” bell rang.

School District Superintendent Hollis Merrell described the bell to the station:

"It audibly says, 'This is not a drill,' but it doesn't give any indication as to what may be happening at the school. It's just locked down. This is not a drill. The police are on their way," Merrell said.

The Taylor-Snowflake Police Department approached the school to make the active shooter drill more realistic. It was designed to mimic a real emergency situation.

Because of the approach, students, some staff, and parents were unaware of the drill. Some students assumed the worse and texted parents that there was an active shooter on campus.

Police Chief Robert Martin said the unannounced drill idea came after a previous drill in late 2024 where he felt students were not taking the drill seriously.

Obviously, students should take every drill seriously. But that sometimes doesn’t happen. High schoolers can simply be high schoolers and not understand how important drills are to prepare the school community.

I understand Chief Martin’s frustrations, but the unannounced drill likely took the situation too far.

Communication and trust between everyone are undeniably important parts of school security at any level. While students at Snowflake High School will likely start taking drills more seriously, why dent those bonds between the school, community at large, and law enforcement? There are better ways to make the point.

This article originally appeared in the May / June 2025 issue of Campus Security Today.

About the Author

Brent Dirks is senior editor for Security Today and Campus Security Today magazines.

Featured

  • Electrified Latch Retraction Locks Key Benefits for Retrofits

    Building owners and facility managers increasingly rely on electrified hardware to enhance security while meeting accessibility standards. Among these technologies, electrified or motorized latch retraction locks are especially effective for retrofit projects where existing door and frame conditions complicate upgrades. Latch retraction capable locks combine security, accessibility and code compliance benefits, making them ideal for retrofitting fire-rated and non-rated openings in schools, healthcare facilities, commercial buildings and more. Read Now

  • How Cloud Security Solutions Are Transforming Campus Safety

    Campus administrators today face a challenging mandate: deliver stronger security across their facilities while working within tighter budget constraints. From school districts focused on student safety to hospitals protecting patients and staff, the question remains the same: how do you build security infrastructure that evolves with your needs without requiring massive capital investments? Read Now

  • Rethinking Campus Security From the Inside

    For decades, campus security strategies focused on keeping threats outside school walls. But since the tragedy at Columbine High School, data has shown that many attacks begin inside the building, often in classrooms and corridors. This shift has prompted schools to rethink security from the inside and place greater emphasis on interior elements such as classroom doors. This shift is evidenced by a new generation of classroom door systems engineered to delay inside intruders and an ASTM standard that raises the bar on how these systems must be designed to defend against attack. Read Now

  • AI in Security: Advancing Campus Safety and Considerations for Implementing

    Artificial intelligence (AI) continues to capture attention across every sector, and the physical security industry is no exception. Once seen as experimental, AI-enabled analytics now underpin how organizations monitor environments, detect threats, and make decisions. What was once futuristic is now a practical necessity for safety professionals managing growing volumes of data, tighter resources, and increasing expectations for faster, more accurate responses. Read Now

Most   Popular