Ohio Appeals Court Overturns School District Policy For Arming Staff Members

Concerned parents sued the Madison Local School District over its training requirements for staff members to carry a concealed weapon. Now, those policies have been struck down.

In a March 30 decision, the Ohio Court of Appeals ruled against a school district policy that allowed staff members to be armed with concealed weapons if they had a license and completed 24 hours of active shooter training.

The 2-1 vote by the appeals panel struck down the policy of the Madison Local School District, which claimed that its staff members’ classification as “approved volunteers” exempted them from state training requirements for armed school guards and peace officers.

The court found that the Madison Local policy conflicted with state law, which requires any person who “goes armed while on duty” at an educational institution to complete peace officer training, which is currently a minimum of 728 hours, Education Week reported.

"The 'approved volunteer' designation does not alter the inevitable conclusion that the Madison Local employees are 'armed while on duty,'" the judges wrote in their March 30 majority opinion on Gabbard v. Madison Local School District, according to Education Week. "Madison Local cannot unilaterally change the training requirements set forth by the General Assembly."

The school district, which serves about 1,500 students in southwest Ohio, implemented the policy after a student opened fire on his classmates in the Madison junior/high school cafeteria in February 2016. No one was killed in the incident, but four were injured.

Five concerned parents, backed by Everytown for Gun Safety, sued the school district over the policy in 2018 amid growing calls for arming teachers after the Parkland high school shooting.

“For good reason, Ohio requires that teachers undergo extensive training before carrying hidden, loaded handguns in classrooms,” Rachel Bloomekatz, a Columbus-based attorney who worked on the case, said in a statement. “As the court recognized, the district’s program fails to meet the state’s clear requirements. We’re pleased by today’s ruling and believe it will improve the safety of students, teachers and staff.”

The decision overturns a 2019 lower court decision that denied an injunction on the district’s policy, but ordered Madison Local to publicly release previously secret policies and procedures for armed staff. Both courts have protected psychological evaluations of armed staff from public release, matter that is still the subject of “ongoing litigation,” according to Everytown Law.

In a statement to local news outlets, Madison Local’s Board of Education said they were disappointed in the “split decision” issued by the court, but were heartened by the dissenting judge’s opinion as well as support from the Ohio attorney general.

“While this policy has received a substantial amount of attention, it is just one of the many steps that the District has taken to ensure student safety,” the Madison statement reads. “We are considering and exploring all of our options moving forward, including, if necessary, asking the Ohio Supreme Court to intervene.”

About the Author

Haley Samsel is an Associate Content Editor for the Infrastructure Solutions Group at 1105 Media.


  • Making Safety and Security Intrinsic to School Design

    Public anxieties about school safety are escalating across the country. According to a 2023 Gallup report, 44% of parents fear for their child’s physical safety at school, a 10 percentage-point increase since 2019. Unfortunately, these fears are likely to increase if the incidence of school tragedies continues to mount. As a result, school leaders are now charged with two non-negotiable responsibilities. The first, as always, is to ensure kids have what they need to learn, grow, and thrive. Sadly, their second responsibility is to keep the children in their care safe from threats and physical danger. Read Now

  • Unlocking Peace of Mind

    In a perfect world, every school would have an unlimited budget to help secure their schools. In reality, schools must prioritize what budget they have while navigating the complexities surrounding school security and lockdown Read Now

  • Emerging Campus Access Control Solutions

    Emerging solutions in campus access control can mean different things. Usually, we expect the topic to focus on the very latest in door security products and solutions that have just been recently released or are about to be launched. After all, staying up on improvements to keep campuses safer is critical. Plus, it’s always interesting and exciting to learn what’s new and how innovations are going to better protect lives and assets and help the industry be even more successful. Read Now

  • Here’s How Instructional Audio Can Play a Key Role in School Safety

    Ensuring the safety of students and employees is critical in today’s educational environment. While the threat of a school shooting is in the back of everyone’s mind, the truth is there are many possible scenarios that could crop up at any time in classrooms, hallways, and other school spaces—from fights or altercations to a sick child or staff member who requires emergency attention. Read Now