ucla sign

UCLA Abandons Plans To Use Facial Recognition On Campus After Students Voice Concerns

The university publicly disclosed that it was considering adding facial recognition software to its security operations, but backed away from the proposal after students and faculty voiced their opposition.

Following sustained protests from students, the University of California, Los Angeles announced that it would drop its plans to use facial recognition software as part of its campus security strategy.

The technology had originally been proposed last year, with students having the opportunity to comment on the policy in June. Many voiced concerns, and thanks to a campaign by digital rights organization Fight for the Future, those concerns were elevated through protests and social media campaigns.

In response, UCLA administrators told Fight for the Future last month that they would no longer pursue the use of facial recognition on campus.

“We have determined that the potential benefits are limited and are vastly outweighed by the concerns of the campus community,” Michael Beck, a vice chancellor at the school, told Evan Greer, the deputy director of Fight for the Future, in an email.

In a statement, student activist Matthew William Richard said that he was excited to see that UCLA listened to its students, workers, faculty and community by deciding to abandon its plans.

“We hope other universities see that they will not get away with these policies,” Richard, a third-year student at UCLA, said. “We hope UCLA continues their progress by specifically codifying this prohibition of software and creating infrastructure to legitimize our voices going forward; together we can demilitarize and democratize our campuses.”

Prior to UCLA’s announcement, Fight for the Future had contacted administrators about the results of an experiment its researchers had done to show the potential issues with using facial recognition for campus security purposes. Using Amazon’s Rekognition software, the organization ran 400 photos of UCLA’s football and basketball teams along with faculty members through a mugshot database.

Of those images, 58 photos of student-athletes or faculty members were falsely matched with mugshots in the database. Most of those images featured people of color, showing the potential accuracy issues that the university would have faced had it adopted facial recognition.

“I’m glad the administration listened to the community and is abandoning this plan,” Kimberlé Crenshaw, a UCLA law professor who developed the academic definition of intersectionality and was incorrectly matched with a mugshot photo, said in a statement. “Other school administrators should follow suit. Racially biased surveillance does not make our communities safer.”

Fight for the Future keeps a scorecard of universities that have publicly disclosed their policies on facial recognition, but many have not responded. This means that many universities could be using the technology already but are not coming forward about their policies.

“There are really no laws in place that would require private institutions, for example, to even disclose to their students that they’re doing this,” Greer told Inside Higher Ed. “We really do need policies in place so that it’s not up to school administrators.”

About the Author

Haley Samsel is an Associate Content Editor for the Infrastructure Solutions Group at 1105 Media.

Featured

  • Buffalo Public School District Modernizes Security With New Cameras NVRs

    i-PRO Co., Ltd. (formerly Panasonic Security), a provider of professional security solutions for surveillance and public safety, recently announced that the Buffalo Public School District (BPSD) has modernized its security footprint with i-PRO multi-sensor and 360° fisheye network cameras, and i-PRO NV300 network video recorders (NVR). The BPSD serves 28,000 K-12 students out of 70 facilities in western New York. Read Now

  • Lessons Learned from Past School Shootings

    Two experts are working together and collaborating on new ways school campuses can develop a proactive and comprehensive security plan. For three consecutive years, the U.S has had a record-high number of school shootings resulting in a repetitive cycle of grievances, anger, and frustration. The U.S. had 344 school shootings in 2023 which surpassed the record-breaking number of 308 school shootings in 2022 as reported by K-12 School Shooting Database. Read Now

  • Mother of Michigan School Shooter Found Guilty on Four Counts of Involuntary Manslaughter

    The mother of the teenager who killed four students in an Oxford, Michigan school has been found guilty of four counts of involuntary manslaughter because of the shooting. That’s according to a report from CNN. Read Now

  • Utah State Legislature Funds Gun Detection Technology and Incident Management System in All Public K-12 Schools

    ZeroEyes, the creators of the only AI-based gun detection video analytics platform that holds the US Department of Homeland Security SAFETY Act Designation, and AEGIX Global, a Utah-based provider of industry-leading critical incident management services, recently announced that the Utah State Board of Education has approved a contract to provide the joint solution for all Utah public K-12 schools, including charter schools. Read Now

Webinars