Sandy Hook Parents Lose State Court Appeal in School Safety Lawsuit

Sandy Hook Parents Lose State Court Appeal in School Safety Lawsuit

Sandy Hook plaintiffs alleged the school failed to follow a mandated security protocol in the December 2012 shooting. The appeals court agreed with a lower court judge that governmental immunity shielded the defendants.

The appeals court ruled 3-0 against the parents of Jesse Lewis and Noah Pozner on Friday, agreeing with a lower court judge that governmental immunity shielded the defendants. The two families alleged negligence and inadequate school-safety protocols contributed to the death of their children during the Sandy Hook Elementary School shooting in December 2012.

The parents alleged that school officials failed to follow a mandated security protocol and order a lockdown that may have saved lives immediately after the gunman shot his way into the school. Moreover, they faulted the school for having classroom doors that could not be locked from inside the classroom.

In May 2018, at trial, Danbury Superior Court Judge Robin Wilson focused her decision primarily on government immunity. The appellate court agreed with Wilson and affirmed her ruling.

“The plaintiffs also claim that the trail court erred in rendering summary judgement because the school security guidelines adopted by the defendants imposed upon the school faculty and staff a ministerial duty to act in a prescribed manner during the shooting,” Judge Thomas Bishop wrote for the appellate panel. “The language in the guidelines referenced by the plaintiffs contradicts this claim.”

According to law.com, the plaintiffs claimed in their appellate oral argument that the defendants left the school’s faculty and staff in a position in which they failed or could not adhere to mandatory school security guidelines. However, the defendants’ rebuttal was a successful motion for summary judgment statin they were entitled to government immunity pursuant to the Connecticut General Statutes, and that there was no genuine issue of material fact regarding the alleged negligence.

“The school security guidelines contained qualifying language such as ‘may’ or ‘should,’ which indicated that the school faculty and staff had discretion to exercise judgment in following them,” Bishop wrote in the ruling.

About the Author

Kaitlyn DeHaven is the Associate Content Editor for the Infrastructure Solutions Group at 1105 Media.

Featured

  • Buffalo Public School District Modernizes Security With New Cameras NVRs

    i-PRO Co., Ltd. (formerly Panasonic Security), a provider of professional security solutions for surveillance and public safety, recently announced that the Buffalo Public School District (BPSD) has modernized its security footprint with i-PRO multi-sensor and 360° fisheye network cameras, and i-PRO NV300 network video recorders (NVR). The BPSD serves 28,000 K-12 students out of 70 facilities in western New York. Read Now

  • Lessons Learned from Past School Shootings

    Two experts are working together and collaborating on new ways school campuses can develop a proactive and comprehensive security plan. For three consecutive years, the U.S has had a record-high number of school shootings resulting in a repetitive cycle of grievances, anger, and frustration. The U.S. had 344 school shootings in 2023 which surpassed the record-breaking number of 308 school shootings in 2022 as reported by K-12 School Shooting Database. Read Now

  • Mother of Michigan School Shooter Found Guilty on Four Counts of Involuntary Manslaughter

    The mother of the teenager who killed four students in an Oxford, Michigan school has been found guilty of four counts of involuntary manslaughter because of the shooting. That’s according to a report from CNN. Read Now

  • Utah State Legislature Funds Gun Detection Technology and Incident Management System in All Public K-12 Schools

    ZeroEyes, the creators of the only AI-based gun detection video analytics platform that holds the US Department of Homeland Security SAFETY Act Designation, and AEGIX Global, a Utah-based provider of industry-leading critical incident management services, recently announced that the Utah State Board of Education has approved a contract to provide the joint solution for all Utah public K-12 schools, including charter schools. Read Now

Webinars